Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thoughts on culture & politics, by Robert Stanley Martin
Click here for Pol Culture's Twitter page.
The reviews here are intended as journalistic critiques of the works in question, not promotional or advertising copy.
This site occasionally reviews material that was provided free of charge by the publisher or producer. Readers should assume that this is the case with all posted reviews. Government agencies should not assume that all materials reviewed here are gifts subject to taxation. The site author maintains private records of which material was lent, bought, or rented, and which was provided free of charge by outside parties. This paragraph is intended only as a caveat lecteur.
The site is also a participant in the Powell's Books Partnership Program. At or near the top of each review, a link is provided to the Web page where the work can be purchased on the Powell's Books Web site. The site receives a small percentage of the price of each item purchased from Powell's after following the link. This is offered as a service to interested readers that also provides an opportunity to support this site.
This notice is intended to bring this Web site into compliance with Federal Trade Commission 16 CFR Part 255.
Disclaimer posted October 7, 2009.
© 2008-2013 Robert Stanley Martin
1 comment:
Very perceptive review. My take on the film's faults is that the script is simply not sharp enough to support the scaffolding Anderson constructed. As far as the screenwriting is concerned, his reach is bigger than his grasp. With a good script, everything else would have fallen in place. As it stands, the ending he concocted is one of the flattest and most curious in recent movie history. Paul Dano's performance was another major problem. He was far too young and inexperienced for the role. Things were forced way too much. It would have been better to use someone with enough gravitas capable of holding their own against Lewis. Another thing is that Dano played the religious part at times too mockingly, to the point of being cartoonish. This approach is not original. It would have been better to play things straight and allow any comedy to bubble up naturally. Here's hoping that Anderson gets a real screenwriter for his future projects. Magnolia remains his best film, as imperfect as it was.
Post a Comment